The Top 5 Criminal Defence Strategies Every Client Should Know

Facing criminal charges in Toronto can be a daunting experience. Understanding the key defence strategies employed by criminal defence lawyers could help empower you and relieve some of the anxiety surrounding the legal process. 

Whether you are seeking legal representation or looking to better understand the possible tactics your defence lawyer may employ, being informed about these strategies can be invaluable. By gaining knowledge about the different approaches utilized in criminal cases, you’ll be better equipped to partner with your legal counsel and navigate your case with confidence. In this article, we will explore the top five criminal defence strategies that have proven effective in achieving successful outcomes for clients in Toronto.

1. Challenging the Evidence and its Admissibility

A popular defence strategy in criminal cases revolves around questioning the evidence presented by the prosecution. Your defence lawyer may challenge the credibility, accuracy, and admissibility of the evidence, seeking to weaken the prosecution’s case. For instance, if law enforcement obtained evidence through illegal means, such as violating your constitutional rights, your lawyer could file a motion to exclude that evidence from the trial. Additionally, if the prosecution relies heavily on forensic evidence, your lawyer may consult with experts to scrutinize the methodological validity of the evidence and possibly cast doubt on its accuracy.

2. Discrediting Prosecution Witnesses

It is crucial to identify any inconsistencies or motives to lie in the testimonies provided by the prosecution witnesses, as they play a vital role in building the case against you. Your criminal defence lawyer may use cross-examination to challenge the credibility of these witnesses, potentially discrediting their testimonies. Factors that can undermine a witness’s credibility include a history of dishonesty, biases, potential motives, or contradictions in their statements. If successful, your lawyer may weaken the prosecution’s case, strengthening your defence and increasing your chances of a favourable outcome.

3. Providing an Alibi Defence

An alibi defence is a powerful strategy if you can prove that you were somewhere else when the alleged crime took place. To establish an alibi, your lawyer will gather evidence such as witness testimonies, security footage, transaction records, or digital evidence, such as cell phone location data, to confirm that you were not at the scene. By presenting an alibi defence, your lawyer effectively refutes the possibility of your involvement and forces the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you were present at the scene and committed the crime. This can be particularly challenging for the prosecution, especially if your legal team has provided credible evidence backing up your alibi.

4. Arguing Self-Defence, Necessity, or Duress

In some cases, your criminal defence lawyer may argue that you acted in self-defence, out of necessity, or under duress when committing the alleged crime. Each of these defences has specific requirements under Canadian law:

– Self-Defence: This defence is appropriate when you can demonstrate that you acted to defend yourself or another person against a reasonable and imminent threat of harm. Your lawyer must convince the judge or jury that your actions were reasonable under the circumstances and you used no more force than necessary to protect yourself or others.

– Necessity: This defence can be applied when your lawyer argues that you committed the crime to avoid imminent and serious harm in a situation where no legal option was available. For this defence to succeed, the harm you sought to prevent must be greater than the harm caused by the criminal act, and there must be no reasonable legal alternative to the act.

– Duress: Your lawyer may argue duress if you committed a crime under the threat of violence or harm against you or your loved ones. To succeed, they must show that you reasonably believed the threat would be carried out if you did not comply and that there was no opportunity to escape or report the threat to the authorities.

5. Raising Reasonable Doubt

In criminal cases, the burden of proof lies with the prosecution, meaning they must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you committed the alleged crime. One of the most effective defence strategies is raising reasonable doubt in the minds of the judge or jury regarding your guilt. Your defence lawyer accomplishes this by questioning the reliability of the evidence, discrediting witnesses, challenging the prosecution’s theories, and presenting alternative explanations for the alleged crime. By introducing reasonable doubt, your lawyer forces the prosecution to meet the high burden of proof, increasing the odds of an acquittal.

Secure Your Best Defence with Experienced Legal Representation

With a better understanding of the top criminal defence strategies, you can actively participate in your case and work closely with your legal counsel. However, navigating the intricacies of each strategy is best left in the hands of experienced criminal defence lawyers like those at Calvin Barry Professional Corporation. Our team is well-versed in the most effective defence strategies and will build a personalized defence tailored to your unique circumstances in the Greater Toronto Area.

If you’re facing criminal charges and require expert legal representation, don’t hesitate to reach out to the professionals at Calvin Barry Professional Corporation. Our skilled criminal defence lawyers in Toronto are committed to protecting your rights and securing the best possible outcome for your case. Contact us today for a consultation, and let our team help you forge a strong defence and navigate the challenges ahead with confidence.

Get In Touch

Contact Calvin Barry Today.

Contact an experienced criminal defence lawyer in Toronto to fight for your case.

Book a Free Consultation